*This entry was originally written about three weeks ago, before the previously posted entry. Because of the sensitive religious issues it touches on it required more editing than usual to be sure I really said what I mean. The events that have occurred here in Japan have frequently led this blog far from a typical travel journal, and I've really enjoyed going a bit deeper and exploring the political and philosophical issues that are embedded in our experiences here. However, this entry stands a better chance than most of exposing our readers to thoughts they may not want to hear. Obviously it's not my intent to offend anyone, but if that's how it is, so be it. We took no photos for the events herein recounted, as they are already well seared into our memories and aren't anything anyone would choose to see anyway. Expect something a little more upbeat next month, and remember that these sad entries only make the happy ones sweeter.
Last Tuesday Hope died. Hope was our pet cat and the reason most of you didn’t know we had a pet cat here is because we only had her for a single day.
Monday night we had our usual family meeting where we light candles, play some music, then sit and talk about what’s going on in our lives. We were both very low, missing the joys of our recent trip home, worn out from the incessant heat and humidity of Kumamoto’s summer, and trying to make sense of what it means for us to be here in Japan for another year. More than usual I was feeling stuck in my life, unable to move ahead with family, job, or my musical aspirations and Brandi was growing increasingly depressed about our difficulty conceiving.
We’ve started seeing a reproductive specialist on a regular basis, and while it has provided some hope of finally moving ahead, what should be a sacred encounter with life’s mystery and magic has been rendered into flow charts, technical jargon, medical tests, and precisely-scheduled romance. I’ve always dreamed of having a poetic sort of life, something romantic with chance encounters, strange coincidences, and deep waters of enveloping mystery. Instead I’ve been born into the age of science and even that last little dusting of magic held in the creation of life is now formulaic and romantic as assembling furniture from a box. I’m still anxious to have a child, but the necessity of doing it this way feels like I’ve been cheated out of something precious that I can’t quite place my finger on. Maybe it’s just one more discrepancy between my life and the “normal” life we’re led to expect, one more of life’s promises falling flat.
Little more than a kitten, the cat’s entire head and front legs were covered with a thick coat of mange, rough and hardened, as though someone had dipped the cat in mud and left it out in the sun. From its eyes ran two rivers of yellow pus, dried black halfway down its face, so thick that we originally thought her to be blind. Her back was arched and threatened to push right through the taut skin and the white fur had mostly fallen out, especially along its long bony tail. Though it was a balmy night, the cat appeared to be shivering and was covered in filth. It had apparently chosen this spot to die.
We were both deeply shaken. Loathing the rational part of my mind that said to avoid a diseased animal, I sought to comfort the small animal. I ran my hand over her and instead of the soft caress of fur, what I felt was sandpapery and hard. She failed to respond to my touch, and unsure what to do we finished our walk to the shrine to pray. Having previously felt so completely sorry for ourselves, this shocking encounter with actual as-bad-as-life-can-get suffering made our self-pity suddenly seem selfish and indulgent. We both found ourselves praying for the animal we had found – that it be released from pain, that it no longer need suffer – our own troubles temporarily forgotten.
But the thought occurred all too quickly that I was offering up a prayer for mercy to the very powers who had allowed this tragedy to occur. I’ve never believed in God as some sort of white-shrouded Santa Claus in the sky, ready to hear my personal pleas and come running. I’ve always taken the concept to be something more metaphorical or symbolic – a word to capture the inherent mystery and beauty of life – and when I pray at these shrines I do hope there is some mysterious, benevolent force listening “out there,” but in true twentieth-century fashion I assume I may just be conversing with a deeper part of my own mind. However, as I sought to connect to some form of deeper reality, I found myself reaching into a well of anger, seething at the nature of fate and the world that allowed such things as this to take place.Hands and eyes clenched, I began sobbing on the shrine steps – for the incredible suffering of an innocent creature, for so many broken promises about how life should be, for the myriad people who passed by this forsaken animal and felt compelled to do nothing, for life’s injustice and arbitrary cruelty making itself felt so poignantly yet again. I’ve often wished for faith, to have the comfort of believing that things really do happen for a reason and that in some indiscernible way there really is a force of benevolence in the universe making sure things turn out right; but witnessing this moment of unconscionable cruelty, completely meaningless suffering, the universe’s inherent nihilism, it became apparent to me that I would never again hope to find something like a purely loving god in this life. Whatever god there may be condones at some point and time every cruelty imaginable, is as much malevolent hellfire and glowing white light, and is clearly a lot more complicated than most religions will concede.
I pulled myself together and vowed not to be the person who did nothing. To hell with fate. I went back to the hand-washing station, where everyone approaching the shrine purifies themselves, and took one of the hand-drying towels, leaving a 100-yen coin in its place. We took the towel and wrapped up the small animal. When Brandi picked her up, she let out a loud meow of protest, but didn’t struggle. After that she curled into Brandi’s arm for the rest of the walk home. On the way we decided to name her “Hope.” I later remarked that we must be masochistically optimistic to find an animal on the verge of death and give it a name like that, but on reflection it really is only in the face of despair that that idea of hope becomes meaningful – to press on even in the face of utter futility for a just cause is the most noble thing a human can do.
While Brandi set up a small bed in a cardboard box and gave Hope a dish of water (which she drank up like a sponge) I walked to the nearest conbini and tried to find wet cat food. I came back with a carton of milk and some finely chopped fish. Though Hope (who we’d taken to calling “Kibou,” Japanese for “hope”) wouldn’t eat, she continued to drink thirstily and even meowed a few more times, leading us to think she might be healthier than she appeared. Brandi cleaned her with a wet rag and she finally lay down to sleep. I went online to research her malady and figured out that it was mange, caused by parasitic mites, and very much treatable. It was disheartening to find, however, not a single picture anywhere online even remotely as awful as our new cat looked. I located a nearby vet and we made plans for Brandi to take her in while I was at work the next day.
The next day at the vet Brandi took care to explain to the veterinarians (in Japanese) that we had found a stray animal and that if they couldn’t help it, would they please stop her pain. The veterinarians were taken aback by the extent to which Hope was afflicted, but gave her an IV for dehydration and sent Brandi home with a plastic syringe for feeding. The explained that Hope was too malnourished to treat for the mites just yet, but if we could get her healthy enough they would take care of it. Apparently this sort of affliction is fairly rare in cats and the only reason it progressed so far was that she was malnourished and lacked the resources to fight off the parasites. It turned out that she had recently had a litter of kittens and creating then nursing them had left her without enough strength to keep herself alive. I began to think of the parallels between us finding a cat killed by procreation even as our own lack of children seemed to be wearing our lives down little by little, but I cut the line of thinking off short. The intertwined nature of birth and death are somehow altogether evident, yet too painful to confront directly, like staring at the sun.
Brandi sent me constant text message updates as the cat managed to eat, drink, meow, and even go to the bathroom. We both began entertaining fantasies of slowly nursing her back to health and one day taking her with us back to the States. However, after eating she quickly took a turn for the worse and by early afternoon she was gone. Brandi and I walked her back to the vet to find out what the proper procedure was here in Japan. The vet (who never charged us a thing for all their help) accepted the limp body and let us know that she would be cremated with the other deceased animals from the vet. We thanked him and left, teary-eyed, but grateful Hope’s suffering had ended.
As we slowly returned to the apartment, I remember thinking about all the people who walked by the suffering cat and did nothing, and how they were now living their normal lives while we were here in pain for trying to do the right thing. They certainly saved themselves from the suffering that accompanies this sort of compassion, but at what cost? To see suffering first hand and choose to do nothing, what does that do to a person? I’m inclined to think that those who flee from potent suffering exclude themselves as well from profound joy. I also think that a refusal to acknowledge and address the pain of the world makes a person something less than human. To ignore the sanctity of another unique and precious life – doesn’t it imply a devaluing of life generally, even your own? On the other hand, I’m not myself a vegetarian yet, and I don’t do anything about the treatable diseases and lack of water killing millions in Africa, etc… so maybe the truth is it’s simply easier to live with hypocrisy than we like to admit. Some truly kind and decent people could have seen what we saw, shaken their head in shame, and walked on. I don’t know why but neither Brandi nor I could have slept the night if we had just gone and left the cat as it was. This wasn’t the first animal we brought home to die and probably won’t be the last. Ever and ever I will choose a meaningful suffering over a numb apathy. In material terms, our efforts were ultimately futile, and on a long enough timeline maybe that’s always how it is. However, we appeased a thirst, fed a hunger, gave a dying creature a modicum of safety and comfort to end her life in, and gave a name to a creature that had probably never experienced the slightest caring from another and that would have died anonymously. If that doesn’t matter I don’t know what does.
It took nearly a week to shake the malaise of that 24-hour period. At the end of the day, I did get a taste of a “poetic life,” something surreal and uncanny, something that cannot be reconciled to the mechanistic ways of modern life - something inexplicably subjective, powerfully emotional, bathed in unquantifiable significance, interwoven with the fundamental life substance from which we derive concepts like mercy, truth, and beauty. Since then, Brandi and I have talked a lot about God and have decided that we’re not “on speaking terms” with the Almighty, whatever it may be. It’s easy to say that God was working through us by sending us there, or that bitter experiences like that are necessary for us to know life’s joys and goodness, or that the life we have is miracle enough without expecting more. But I have no need for apologetics – there’s just no excuse for what that poor animal went through.
How do people keep their faith in the face of the incessant, pointless suffering that fills the world? How can anyone think himself a sinner when confronted with the everyday crimes of the Divine? I’ve come to believe that as humans we are on our own, a speck of dust in an indifferent universe. Religious ideals like mercy, beauty, freedom, and justice are not sacred forms “out there” to be discovered, but something we as humans create. As such, our highest calling as humans is to create a far better world than the one given us. Perhaps this is the mission for which God created us? I won’t argue with that, I guess because I don’t want to offend those need faith, and because part of me hopes it’s true. Still, it’s clearly not enough to wait for Godot .
In the end, maybe the silver lining of a painful loss is that we can know the fully-human joy of choosing to keep hope in spite of every rational instinct urging us to quit. I choose to press on and help the next suffering creature, and the one after that, and the one after that, and refuse to succumb to the endless procession of pain that is this world we live in. We’ll have our baby eventually, I’ll find a career I can pour my life into, and we’ll reunite with friends and family. We’ll leave what’s God’s to God and do everything in our own power to push back the darkness and make a world more worth living in.










